All this recent hubbub over the return of Dunkaroos has me in a bit of a nostalgic mood. Not necessarily because of Dunkaroos - I was a bit too old for that fad -but it did get me thinking about things from childhood and why we collect and get fixated on certain items. Take stationery. I’d venture that if you ask yourself why you’re stationery obsessed (and if you’re reading this blog, “stationery obsessed” is an accurate description), two things come up: (1) You’ve always been this way, going to back to when you were a kid; and (2) as you’ve grown, you have, at times, found yourself thinking back to certain pens/pencils/notebooks that you remember fondly and wondering whatever happened to them. For me, this resulted in a six-month eBay quest to accumulate a full gross of my favorite school pencil, the Blackfeet Indian Pencil. While reason eventually took hold and I managed to stop myself after buying up six dozen, I don’t regret this little adventure at all.
Background on the Blackfeet Indian Pencil
Those of us who grew up in the 1980s and 1990s probably may remember the Blackfeet Indian Pencil for its promotional gift set, featuring a dozen pencils in a cedar box stamped with a Remington-esque logo. The pencils were made by the Blackfeet Indian Writing Company, founded in 1972 and located on the Blackfeet Indian Reservation in Browning, Montana. Until its closure in the late 1990s, the Blackfeet Indian Writing Company manufactured writing pencils, art pencils, pens (which I’ve never seen but are also available on eBay). Apparently the company passed from tribal control into private hands around 1992, and subsequently went out of business not too long after.
The Blackfeet Indian Pencil Company released multiple versions of their pencil over the years. Shown here are two, with both black and gold writing/ferrule combinations. The font and graphics on the pencils themselves also changed. The particular box shown here was a promotional gift for a building supply wholesaler in Montana and North Dakota.
I received a dozen of these pencils, in the commemorative box, for Christmas one year when I was 12 or 13, which must have placed the timing towards the end of the company’s run. I remember seeing these for sale at The Nature Company and museum gift shops, which I assume is where my parents (probably my Dad) picked these up. I mostly used yellow No. 2 pencils (Faber-Castell Americans) throughout my school years, so the fact that these are natural pencils probably made them stand out in my mind as something different. I loved the fact that they wrote darker than the Faber-Castell American, which has a firmer core, yet lasted a long time. I had a few of these pencils left well into college, so I probably picked up a few dozen more along the way after that initial batch.
I’m not the only to stockpile this pencil. I didn’t know this when I set out on my journey to track it down, but apparently the Blackfeet Indian Pencil has developed its own cult following over the years. For example, the composer John Luther Adams disclosed in a Facebook post a couple of years ago that he uses Blackfeet Indian Pencils to compose, and Ticonderogas for general writing. The “Blackfeet craze” isn’t quite as pronounced as the hype surrounding the original Blackwing, but eBay pricing has steadily risen. Good thing I have 6 dozen.
In terms of lacquered finish, the closest match is the USA-made Ticonderoga Natural on the left. Yes, I have a mini-stash of those too. No, they’re not for sale, and if you make me a trade offer, it had better be good.
So What’s the Verdict, and Where Do I Get This Pencil?
Is the Blackfeet Indian Pencil as good as I remember it? Yes, it is. While certainly not a luxury pencil on par with a Blackwing or a Palomino, this pencil holds its own with its contemporaries (the Ticonderoga Natural) as well as modern equivalents like the General’s Cedar Pointe and Musgrave’s new “Tennessee Red” (discussed further below). Honestly, unless you have a nostalgic connection to this pencil or are a collector who wants to own a piece of history, you can find similar pencils for MUCH less money, and at around $20-30 per dozen (what I’d consider the reasonable eBay rate for Blackfeet Indian Pencils) the Blackwing Natural probably gives you better performance and feel at that price point. In my case, however, I have no regrets due to the personal connection. I’m glad I’ll have a stash of these pencils for a long time to come.
The graphite on the Blackfeet Indian Pencil, the General’s Cedar Pointe No. 2, and the Ticonderoga Natural appear close to identical, though the feel of the Blackfeet and the Cedar Pointe is so close that it has me thinking they might even share a core. Both the Blackwing Natural “extra firm” and the Musgrave Tennessee Red feature much darker graphite.
If you’d like to source a box of Blackfeet Indian Pencils for your own collection, you’re probably reduced to scouring flea markets, garage sales, and eBay. At any given time, there are multiple eBay listings for Blackfeet Pencils. While some sellers are asking $60-100 for a set of pencils in the cedar box, it’s still relatively easy to find loose pencils and even full packs for $20-30 if you’re patient, which can be less than the cost of a Blackwing Volumes edition, so we’re not talking vintage Blackwing money or anything close.
If you’d like a set of beautiful cedar pencils in a commemorative box, and don’t want to pay out the nose on eBay, I’d suggest that you opt for a set of two dozen Musgrave “Tennessee Reds.”
Alternatives to the Blackfeet Indian Pencil
General’s Cedar Pointe No. 2 is the closest match. While the Blackfeet Indian Pencil is coated in a clear lacquer and General leaves the Cedar Pointe unfinished, the pencil offers a similar aesthetic (natural pencil, black ferrule) and the cores are so close on the two (at least the two specific pencils I’m using) that it makes me wonder whether the Blackfeet Writing Company might have sourced them from General.
For a natural pencil with a lacquered finish, you can of course try the Blackwing Natural, which has a softer core despite containing Blackwing’s “firm” graphite, and also the new Musgrave “Tennessee Red,” which has its own lacquered cedar aesthetic, made even more interesting by the fact that Musgrave is now using actual red cedar - a pencil-making material common more than a hundred years ago - as opposed to the incense cedar commonly used to make modern pencils. I just purchased a box of these in their own commemorative cedar packaging and they’re gorgeous.
Pencil reviews are some of the most popular content here at The Gentleman Stationer, and I promise I’ll try to do more, as I use a lot of pencils (and have quite a stockpile).
Disclaimer: I purchased the pencils featured in this review with my own funds, for my own use.